As the anticipation builds for Matt Reeves’ highly awaited sequel, The Batman Part II, fans are buzzing with excitement over potential cast updates. Among the swirling rumors is the intriguing possibility of Scarlett Johansson migrating from Marvel to the DC universe, stirring discussions on what character she might portray.
Before we dive into our character picks, let’s clarify: this exploration prioritizes characters beyond the expected Poison Ivy, aiming instead for deeper options that align with Reeves’ gritty interpretation of Gotham.
1. Silver St. Cloud

Johansson’s undeniable ability to embody strong, nuanced characters could perfectly lend itself to Silver St. Cloud, an underused romantic interest for Bruce Wayne. This character’s charm lies in her ability to communicate effectively and blend into Bruce’s chaotic life, particularly following the tumultuous relationship he had with Catwoman. St. Cloud offers a fresh perspective, bringing emotional depth to Wayne’s journey.
2. Vicki Vale

As Bruce grapples with his dual life, introducing Vicki Vale could serve as a catalyst for his character development. Vale’s tenacity as a reporter could shed light on Bruce’s hidden layers, pushing him to reconcile his socialite persona with his Batman duties. Johansson’s real-life marriage to comedian Colin Jost could even inspire amusing moments of press inquiries that challenge Wayne’s calm facade.
3. Julia Pennyworth

What if the film explored Alfred Pennyworth’s complex relationship with his daughter, Julia? This character can introduce a familial tension while also being an asset in Batman’s crime-fighting efforts. Julia’s unique storyline could offer fresh dynamics, allowing Johansson to showcase both vulnerability and strength.
4. Nora Fries

Imagine Johansson as Nora Fries, the beloved of the iconic Mr. Freeze. This role would add a chilling layer to her character while interweaving her story with a villain whose motives stem from love and loss. The wintery Chicago backdrop could contrast beautifully with the somber tones of the previous film, inviting a new aesthetic.
5. Helena Bertinelli/Huntress

Introducing Helena Bertinelli, also known as the Huntress, could provide a thrilling dynamic in Gotham. As another vigilante, she could challenge Batman’s solitary approach, allowing them to team up against the Penguin’s underworld. Johansson’s past roles demonstrate her capability to portray strong, action-ready characters, making Huntress a natural fit.
What are the prospects for Scarlett Johansson’s role in The Batman Part II? Only time will tell. However, if any of these suggestions become a reality, the film could see an exciting mix of complex characters and thrilling narratives. The film is slated for release in 2027.
Want to know more about the evolving Marvel and DC cinematic universes? Explore the latest news and insights at Moyens I/O.