Krampus has returned for the 2025 edition of Phasmophobia’s festive Winter’s Jest event, and he’s bringing a unique twist with the Naughty-or-Nice List. This new feature wasn’t part of the previous event, so you might find yourself a bit puzzled about how to tackle it. Don’t worry—I’m here to walk you through the steps to successfully help Krampus gather his goodies.
How to Contribute to the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia
To make Krampus happy, you’re on a mission to locate, collect, and return all items listed on the brown sack in each event map. Think of yourself as Krampus’s helper, gathering prizes to earn some sweet event points.
Where to Spot the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia
The Naughty-or-Nice List can be found attached to a brown sack located by the front door of all active event maps each day. Keep in mind that this list is different for every map, so pay attention as you explore!
How to Locate Items for Krampus’s Naughty-or-Nice List
Your treasure hunt for Krampus’s Naughty-or-Nice List items begins by exploring the active event maps. Each day features four decorated locations where small gifts will be scattered on tables, floors, or almost anywhere you can think of. Pick these up and drop them into the sack to complete your mission and rack up those event points.
What Items Should You Place in the Winter’s Jest Sack?
The items you’ll need for the sack include small gifts tucked away around the event map locations. The specific items vary daily and can be identified next to each name on your list. As you add them to the sack, they’ll be checked off, which helps keep your progress in check.
All Naughty-or-Nice List Items in Phasmophobia
There are a total of 12 festive items to track down for the Naughty-or-Nice List sack. Generally, you only need to find some of them, depending on the day’s particular list. Confused about what’s needed? Here’s a handy rundown to help you spot each item and where to search.
| Item | Image | Bag icon | List | Where to find |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coal |  |
 |
Naughty | Near fireplaces, on tables, and on the ground |
| Gingerbread Cookie |  |
 |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Mini Christmas Trees |  |
 |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Holiday Star |  |
 |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Bear |  |
 |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Trash |  |
 |
Naughty | Close to trash cans, in sinks |
| Elf doll |  |
 |
Nice | On tables, sinks, and other surfaces |
| Sticks |  |
 |
Naughty | On the ground and on other surfaces |
| Candy Cane |  |
 |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Nutcracker |  |
 |
Nice | On boxes and other surfaces |
| Reindeer |  |
 |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Snowman |  |
 |
Nice | On tables, boxes, and other surfaces |
Most items can be found in places you’d expect them to thrive. For instance, Gingerbread Cookies and Candy Canes gravitate toward kitchens and dining areas, while Coal tends to hang around fireplaces.
What Happens After Completing the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia?
Once you toss all the required items into the Naughty-or-Nice List sack, a red box will pop out and land nearby. Interact with it to claim a special prize. The first box I opened revealed a snowball gun, while others contained cookies and random gear, like a Tier I Incense or a Tier II Spirit Box.
The contents of these boxes offer playful nods to past winter events and useful items. You can even munch on a cookie to regain some sanity, working like Tier I Sanity Medication.
If you toss in an item that’s not on the sack at any time, it will fill with coal. A red box will appear, but this time it’ll contain coal instead of a fun prize. Unfortunately, you can’t add any more items after this, so you’ll have to start fresh in a new contract.
To rack up even more event points, don’t forget to open all the Krampus jack-in-the-boxes you encounter on your adventure!
How can I find the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia?
You can find the Naughty-or-Nice List attached to a brown sack near the front door of active event maps.
What items do I need for Krampus’s Naughty-or-Nice List?
You’ll need to collect various festive items like gifts, cookies, and other decorations scattered across the event maps.
What rewards do you get from completing the Naughty-or-Nice List?
Completing the Naughty-or-Nice List rewards you with a special prize, which can include items like a snowball gun or other useful gear.
What happens if I put in the wrong item?
If you accidentally add an incorrect item, the sack will fill with coal, and you won’t be able to recover. A coal-filled box will pop out instead of a prize.
Where can I find the best hiding spots for items?
Items are often hidden on tables, floors, and around fireplaces, so keep an eye out in those areas as you explore.
Feeling excited to tackle Krampus’s challenge? What item do you think you’ll search for first? Share your thoughts in the comments below!