As kids, we often found ourselves deeply immersed in comic books, debating the merits of our favorite heroes. Some were die-hard fans of Batman’s grit, while others admired Spider-Man’s agility or Iron Man’s tech genius. However, one name always brought us together: Superman. Over the years, comic books evolved into cartoons and blockbuster movies, ensuring that each generation experienced their own take on the iconic Man of Steel. But recently, being a DC fan hasn’t exactly felt like a badge of honor. After enduring my fair share of teasing, I think that’s about to change with James Gunn’s upcoming Superman (2025), which is already generating a buzz for all the right reasons. Anticipation, criticism, and conversations about tone have filled the air, but now it’s clear: Gunn’s Superman could redefine DC’s cinematic future. Let’s explore what makes this film a standout success, while also addressing its flaws.
Cinematography Evokes Nostalgia
Think back to those moments when you read comic books, allowing your imagination to visualize those stunning scenes. James Gunn’s Superman captures that essence beautifully, translating it to the big screen with intentional cinematography. Each frame resonates like a comic book panel, from Superman’s emblem zooming in during action sequences to Lex Luthor striking a pose before chaos unfolds. You can genuinely feel the love for the source material. And let’s not overlook Krypto, the charming chaos-bringer, who adds delightful flair in every scene.
A standout feature of the cinematography is how it depicts action. Instead of static or rapidly changing angles, the camera flows dynamically with Superman during fights. It feels like you’re soaring alongside him, evading debris and witnessing every punch from the front row. This level of artistic movement makes the action sequences an unparalleled visual experience.
The film’s use of color and light further enhances the nostalgia. The soft, golden tones evoke warmth, almost like a comforting childhood memory. When Superman takes flight with Lois, it doesn’t just feel like a cinematic moment; it transports you straight from the pages of a comic book into a cherished memory, showcasing expert filmmaking at its finest.
The Cast Truly Delivers
Now, let’s talk about casting—the backbone of any successful superhero film. In Superman (2025), James Gunn has pulled out all the stops, assembling a cast that feels like it has leapt directly from comic pages.
First up is David Corenswet as Superman. It’s as if he was destined to don that cape. His portrayal encapsulates everything you would expect from the Man of Steel: innocence, moral strength, and abundant hope. Whether he’s showing kindness to Lex Luthor or rescuing a squirrel from disaster, Corenswet revitalizes Superman’s essence brilliantly. This performance is a masterclass worth studying.
Nathan Fillion as Guy Gardner/Green Lantern perfectly channels the character’s bombastic ego with comedic finesse. His on-screen charisma and iconic hairstyle shine brightly throughout the film.
Rachel Brosnahan embodies Lois Lane with remarkable authenticity. Sharp, courageous, and captivating, she instantly resonates with anyone familiar with the comics. Her performance is undeniably magnetic.
Edi Gathegi as Mister Terrific and Isabela Merced as Hawkgirl also impress, delivering nuanced performances. Gathegi’s calm intellect complements Merced’s fierce energy, showcasing the depth that comes from strong character choices. It’s evident that Gunn has once again excelled at assembling a stellar cast.
As for Lex Luthor, Nicholas Hoult provides an interpretation that’s both annoying and endearing—a slick, humorous presence that might be the best live-action version we’ve seen to date.
Comic Book Storytelling: A Double-Edged Sword
However, not everything works seamlessly. Gunn’s choice to embrace a comic book storytelling style—while a strength for fans—could alienate some viewers. The episodic format, reminiscent of classic Superman issues, might not appeal to those primarily familiar with the more mainstream portrayals of the character. For instance, younger fans or those accustomed to animated series might find this approach disjointed.
While I appreciate the boldness in this storytelling choice, transitioning a nostalgic format to a broader audience isn’t guaranteed to resonate with everyone.
The pacing also poses a challenge. If you’re familiar with the trailers, you’ll feel as though you’ve seen a significant portion of the film’s first act. Yet, once the plot accelerates, you will find yourself fully engaged right until the end credits.
Does Superman Feel Overcrowded?
The initial trailer sparked debates about whether the film features too many heroes and villains, a concern that, surprisingly, isn’t accurate. Yes, Superman has a crowded cast, but it doesn’t detract from the overall experience. While some characters, like Hawkgirl and Jimmy Olsen, could have benefited from additional development, it’s not a major flaw. Given Gunn’s experience with ensemble casts, he successfully navigates the complexity without losing sight of the primary narrative.
Is Watching Superman (2025) Worth Your Time?
Now, the most pressing question: should you watch James Gunn’s Superman (2025)? If you’ve made it this far in the review, I suspect you are already considering tickets. Definitely go for it—especially if you have any passion for superhero films. The movie brings charm, emotional depth, thrilling action, and an unapologetic sense of humor. For instance, there’s even a flying dog in a cape!
If you’re hesitant because the actor portraying Superman isn’t your “classic” choice, consider this: Are you a true fan of Superman and the DC universe, or do you just have a preference for a specific actor? If it’s the former, grab your friends or family—even that casual Marvel enthusiast—and experience Superman (2025) together. And as you watch, keep one mantra in mind: Look Up!
For more insights and content on superheroes and cinema, continue your exploration at Moyens I/O.