The hum of the transporter faded, leaving me standing on solid ground…San Francisco, to be exact. But this wasn’t any ordinary visit; this was the launch of Starfleet Academy, a series daring to blend the classic with the contemporary. With a two-episode premiere, the show plants its flag in familiar territory while boldly exploring uncharted narrative space.
Starfleet Academy has launched out of spacedock—well, come to landing in San Francisco, really—with a two-episode premiere that speaks to two very different sensibilities the show has. The first is more classically Star Trek, even as it does a lot of legwork to introduce us to the kids, teachers, and villains we’ll be spending time with this season, and the second leans more into the kind of young adult vibe the show finds freshness in, albeit with some occasionally jarring results. But while there’s stronger to come in Starfleet Academy‘s debut season, these are two episodes that give us a good picture of what the show can play with in the Star Trek universe.
“Kids These Days”
Remember the first day at a new school? Now amplify that anxiety with a full-blown terror attack. From the jump, Starfleet Academy draws heavily from its predecessor, Discovery, plunging us into the high-stakes landscape of the 32nd century. In the wake of galactic upheaval, Starfleet grapples with its identity, mirroring classic Star Trek scenarios: The USS Athena, brimming with freshly recruited cadets, faces near-crippling assault by the Venari Ral pirates.
This is pure, unadulterated, high-octane Star Trek. Expect grim faces on the bridge as situations spiral, and the crew—new and seasoned—contend with cascading system failures and life-threatening hull breaches. Starfleet Academy wastes no time proving it can deliver this tried-and-true Star Trek fare. It’s delivered with the same bombast as Discovery, offering explosions, eerie alien tech, and that cathartic “competence porn” where individuals calmly execute their duties under immense strain.
What truly elevates the premiere is the clash between Holly Hunter’s Captain/Chancellor Nahla Ake and Paul Giamatti’s Nus Braka. Hunter’s Ake balances playful curiosity with the weight of centuries (she’s part-Lanthanite), while Giamatti feasts on the scenery, delivering a delightfully over-the-top performance. Their chemistry is undeniable, even when Braka remains a holographic menace.
The most significant twist? We’re not just witnessing seasoned veterans; half the cast are *kids* on their first day. These aren’t junior officers but actual children thrust into an extreme crucible, which heightens the stakes. The price of duty in Starfleet Academy is potentially high, and this trial by fire forges the initial bonds between our core cadets.
The main quintet—Caleb, Jay-den, Sam, Genesis, and Darem—show flashes of Starfleet spirit even amidst the chaos. Dynamics quickly emerge, as the cadets try to free the Athena and address a medical crisis involving the wounded first officer, Lura Thok.
Caleb and Darem engage in verbal sparring, representing the reluctant recruit versus the eager honors student. Caleb finds a connection with the reserved Jay-den, a Klingon aspiring to join the sciences. Genesis and Darem bond over shared ambition and the pressures of expectation, while Sam, a spunky hologram, serves as the social glue. While immature vibes surface, the seeds of becoming “the best they can be” are planted.
“Kids These Days” is thematically tied to Caleb’s backstory. A flashback reveals a disillusioned Ake presiding over Braka’s sentencing for food theft, alongside Caleb’s mother (Tatiana Maslany). Caleb escapes becoming a ward of the Federation, leading to a life of crime. This profound failure becomes Academy‘s moral compass.
Ake and Caleb seek redemption: Ake mentors Caleb, aiming to revive Starfleet’s ideals; Caleb hopes for a fresh start. This mirrors the show’s mission: demonstrating that even at the edge of the Star Trek universe, the franchise’s ethos can be passed to new generations, constantly rebuilt through dedication. The explosions echo Discovery, but the belief in progress is what truly matters for Starfleet Academy.
“Beta Test”
Have you ever felt like your personal life was a matter of galactic importance? “Beta Test” kicks off with that premise: Caleb must flirt, or the Federation crumbles! Okay, that might be a *slight* exaggeration, but it encapsulates the episode’s spirit.
“Beta Test” dares to challenge skeptical viewers: How much are they willing to accept Star Trek themes wrapped in an untraditional package? Following the introduction of Ake, who grapples with her faith in Starfleet, Hunter now embodies a cooler, more casual mentor, creating friction with Admiral Vance and Commander Kelrec (Raoul Bhaneja) of the Starfleet War College.
The cadets behave like typical youngsters. Caleb, determined to be a lone wolf, clashes with roommate Darem and butts heads with instructors (including Tig Notaro’s Jett Reno). It’s a deliberate thumbing of the nose at authority.
How does ‘Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’ balance its serious themes with lighter, more youthful elements?
Where the first episode gently invited the audience in, “Beta Test” serves as a test of how much deviation from traditional *Trek* the fanbase will stomach. Everything is exaggerated, looser, edgier. The episode even includes more swearing than possibly the entire history of Trek. But beneath the surface of superficial provocation, “Beta Test” is a strong Star Trek story that leverages the potential of the 32nd century.
Starfleet Academy hosts diplomatic discussions between Admiral Vance and the Betazoid president concerning Betazed’s potential return to the Federation. The stakes are enormous: Betazed, an early member, would bring vital trade routes, territory, and influence. If the Betazoids can’t be swayed, what hope does the Federation have? To rebuild, the Federation aims to demonstrate that it prioritizes its next generation.
Enter Tarima Sadal (Zoe Steiner), the Betazoid president’s daughter and a prominent youth activist. Caleb encounters her while attempting to evade the academy’s security measures, leading to immediate sparks. Mirroring their flirtation, the diplomatic talks experience highs and lows.
This provides a clever lens for traditional Star Trek storytelling. Starfleet Academy reframes the generations-old debate about Starfleet’s identity—scientific exploration or peacekeeping force—as a rivalry between the Academy and the War College. The Federation’s fate rests on Caleb’s ability to charm Tarima during a whale-watching excursion. The show twists grand concepts through a youthful lens.
What is the significance of Betazed in the context of the Federation’s rebuilding efforts?
However, their courtship is cut short when Tarima’s father declares an impasse. Despite bringing worlds back into the fold, the Federation appears unwilling to adapt, clinging to outdated ideals and its old headquarters in Paris. The Betazoids have evolved and seek a partner that acknowledges their progress, not their past. Much like Tarima, they suspect Caleb is more interested in the stellar cartography than her.
With Ake’s prompting, Caleb lowers his guard, convincing Tarima and her father to give him and the Federation another shot. Vance seizes the opportunity, relocating Federation HQ to Betazed—a symbolic gesture. At least for the Federation, the day is won. Caleb learns a tough lesson when Tarima opts for the War College, their feelings complicated by the rivalry between the schools. “Beta Test” reveals Starfleet Academy‘s balancing act, but doesn’t offer easy rewards.
How does ‘Starfleet Academy’s’ depiction of intergenerational relationships influence the show’s overall message?
The show attempts to be a bridge – a way to stay true to Gene Roddenberry’s original vision, whilst also drawing in a new, younger, more digitally native audience. But, is it possible to truly serve two masters?
Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.