The rain hammered against the windows as I refreshed Twitter, another rumor about Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man making a comeback. My hope flared, then fizzled. It’s time to accept that some dreams, especially those involving resurrected superhero sagas, are better left undisturbed.
Raimi’s Final Word on Spider-Man 4
You know how it is: You revisit your old high school, and everything seems smaller, different. Sam Raimi, the director who gave us the original Spider-Man trilogy, seems to feel that way about returning to his version of Peter Parker. After directing Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness for Marvel Studios and seeing Tobey Maguire’s return in Spider-Man: No Way Home, many fans held onto hope that Spider-Man 4 could be revived. Raimi had planned a fourth installment, but Sony chose to reboot the franchise instead. Raimi himself even suggested in recent years that he’d be open to revisiting the project.
But in a recent interview with ScreenRant while promoting his latest movie, Send Help, Raimi stated that he believes his characters have “gone elsewhere,” and that it “wouldn’t be right” for him to return and attempt to “resurrect” his version of the story. He clarified that he maintains his fondness for the character and the producers he collaborated with on the trilogy. He views his time with Spider-Man as a memorable, yet finite, chapter, like a celebrated run on a comic book title.
“For a brief time I was handed the torch to carry on after 40 years of Spider-Man comics. And then after my three movies, I handed the torch off to someone else,” he continued. “And I think they’ve got to keep running with the storyline and the audience that is now following the torchbearer.”
Will Marvel Ever Revive Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man?
Never say never, right? Raimi’s perspective is a dose of realism. For him, the story has reached its natural conclusion. He sees his role as a steward, passing the baton to the next storyteller. But what about Marvel’s plans? Despite Raimi’s closure on the topic, the door might not be entirely shut. After No Way Home reassured viewers that Maguire’s Peter Parker and MJ found their way back to each other, the possibility remains that Marvel could revisit his character. Tom Holland is the current bearer of the torch, but could it be passed back to his predecessor someday?
The Comic Book Run Analogy
Think of your favorite comic book series. Writers and artists come and go, each leaving their mark on the character’s journey. Raimi sees his Spider-Man trilogy in a similar vein: a distinct, self-contained arc within the larger Spider-Man mythology. Each director’s vision is like a different brushstroke on the same canvas. This analogy highlights the collaborative and evolving nature of superhero storytelling, where different creators contribute their unique perspectives to beloved characters.
How Did Spider-Man: No Way Home Affect Things?
No Way Home acted as a pressure release valve, didn’t it? The film gave audiences closure, confirming that Maguire’s Spider-Man found peace. This acknowledgment might give Marvel the freedom to leave that version of the character be. Maybe revisiting him would be gilding the lily. Or it could be seen as an invitation to explore that universe further. The film earned $1.9 billion (€1.77 billion), so there is clearly still an audience.
Is Hope Truly Lost?
Raimi’s words are a splash of cold water. The director appears content to let his Spider-Man rest. He delivered what many consider a high point in superhero cinema, and that’s a legacy to be proud of. Yet, fans will likely continue to hope for Spider-Man 4, maybe even launch a campaign for it. Even with Raimi putting the idea to bed, Marvel might not be entirely done with Maguire’s Spidey. Perhaps, the real question isn’t whether Spider-Man 4 will happen, but should it?
Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.