Get ready for chills and thrills, as Fear Street: Prom Queen is set to debut on Netflix on May 23, 2025. This highly anticipated installment will take us back to the infamous Shadyside, bringing a fresh masked killer and spine-tingling gore that’s bound to make your pulse race. The Fear Street Trilogy, masterminded by R.L. Stine, has captivated fans worldwide with its dark storytelling and eerie settings. Now, Prom Queen promises to continue this legacy, but where does it fit into the Fear Street timeline? Let’s dive into the details.
Fear Street: Prom Queen Timeline Explained

Fear Street: Prom Queen unfolds in 1988, placing it strategically between Fear Street: Part One (set in 1994) and Fear Street: Part Two (1978). The storyline takes place six years before the first movie’s gruesome events and ten years after the second. While the creators haven’t confirmed Sarah Fier’s involvement this time around, the film aims to maintain the intense essence of the trilogy that rocked the horror scene in 2021.
This film operates in the same universe as the original trilogy, yet it stands alone with new characters and a unique undead antagonist seeking vengeance against Prom Queen contestants. Because details remain scarce, a variety of fan theories have surfaced online, fueling excitement and speculation.
The climax of the original trilogy, specifically 1666, revealed that Sarah Fier wasn’t the harbinger of chaos; rather, a “Faustian bargain” was the root cause behind the horrific events. Many fans believe a similar bargain could be exploited in Prom Queen to ignite the new wave of killings.
There’s also talk of possible cameos from survivors of the 1978 massacre, such as Ziggy Berman, although nothing has been officially confirmed. Expect the film to enrich the Fear Street universe with fresh supernatural elements that will enhance its spookiness.
In short, Prom Queen looks poised to be an exciting addition to the Fear Street franchise. Fans ardently hope it will live up to the stellar reputation of the original trilogy released in 2021.
Will the new characters resonate with the audience just as the originals did? That remains to be seen.
What time period does Fear Street: Prom Queen take place in?
Fear Street: Prom Queen is set in 1988, positioned between the events of the first and second films of the trilogy.
Is Fear Street: Prom Queen a sequel or a standalone film?
Fear Street: Prom Queen is a standalone sequel, featuring new characters and a unique storyline while still existing within the Fear Street universe.
Will Sarah Fier be part of the story in Prom Queen?
The creators have not confirmed Sarah Fier’s involvement in Prom Queen, but the film aims to capture the essence of the original trilogy.
Can we expect cameos from previous characters in Prom Queen?
There is speculation about possible cameos from survivors of the 1978 massacre, such as Ziggy Berman, though this remains unconfirmed.
Are there any fan theories about Fear Street: Prom Queen?
Many fans believe that a “Faustian bargain” similar to that in 1666 could be driving the actions of the undead killer in Prom Queen.
As we await the release, stay tuned to explore even more relatable content surrounding the Fear Street franchise. For deeper insights, check out Moyens I/O.