Why Fans Are Upset About the New ‘Lilo & Stitch’ Movie

Why Fans Are Upset About the New 'Lilo & Stitch' Movie

Walt Disney Pictures’ live-action Lilo & Stitch kicked off over Memorial Day weekend and has already made waves at the box office. However, fans of the cherished original film are in for a surprise with the substantial updates made in this adaptation.

io9 spoiler bar

Minor details, such as Pleakley’s distance from drag culture, have caught attention, yet the film portrays the character still embracing feminine outfits. Also, fans are disappointed by the absence of Gantu, the Galactic Federation’s intimidating enforcer. While the animated version underwent significant alterations during production, this new take reflects a different cultural landscape and aims for a more grounded narrative.

Significant Changes in Character Dynamics

The online discourse is heating up regarding Nani’s (Sydney Agudong) custody of her younger sister Lilo (Maia Kealoha). Unlike the 2002 film, where Nani triumphs over the social worker Cobra Bubbles (originally voiced by Ving Rhames), the remake sees her handing guardianship to their neighbor Tutu (Amy Hill). This allows Nani to pursue college while their “found family” dynamic evolves.

Nani’s Struggle for Balance

Nani, depicted as a recent high school graduate, faces the daunting task of holding her little family together, especially with Stitch’s arrival. Tutu, along with Mrs. Kekoa (Tia Carrere, who voiced Nani in the original), helps the sisters maintain their bond while allowing Nani a chance to follow her educational aspirations.

Reinterpreting Ohana’s Meaning

The central theme of “Ohana,” meaning family, resonates throughout both films. The original Lilo & Stitch subtly critiqued Hawaii’s colonial history, showcasing the importance of familial connections. Critics argue that Nani’s choice to entrust Lilo to Tutu undermines this idea, suggesting she relinquishes her family to the system for personal ambitions.

The Impact of Community

This adaptation portrays Nani’s maturation in a community context. The animated film depicted her as older than she was; this remake emphasizes younger women, particularly women of color, grappling with premature responsibilities. Life circumstances compel them to grow up quickly, a theme that resonates with many viewers.

How Has Nani’s Role Changed?

In examining Nani’s character, it becomes evident that she sacrifices her dreams to care for Lilo after their parents’ death, further highlighted by the absence of community in the animated version. Producer Jonathan Eirich explained that including Tutu’s supportive character aimed to reflect the communal spirit of Hawaii, accentuating how neighbors would rally around bereaved family members.

What is the Role of Tutu?

Tutu evolves into both a guardian for Lilo and a pillar of support for Nani. Her character enriches the theme of Ohana, demonstrating that family extends beyond blood relations and emphasizes the community’s role in nurturing youth.

Will the Ending Leave Fans Satisfied?

While the live-action film modifies various elements of the plot, Nani’s development includes newfound solutions that keep her connected with Lilo, addressing past concerns. For instance, Nani acquires a portal gun, allowing her to balance education and home life effortlessly. This twist not only keeps them together but also cleverly addresses familial responsibilities.

Fans are polarized regarding the changes made in the narrative, yet they will inevitably have thoughts on how well the live-action film captures the spirit of the original. It’s essential to recognize that remakes often invite scrutiny, especially with the current atmosphere surrounding Disney’s adaptations.

How does the live-action Lilo & Stitch differ from the animated version? The new adaptation introduces significant character developments and community themes, enriching the narrative in a modern context.

Are there more familial themes in the new film? Yes, the inclusion of community support around Nani and Lilo juxtaposes the isolation depicted in the animated original, offering a fresh perspective on “Ohana.”

How does Tutu’s role enhance the storyline? Tutu provides not just oversight for Lilo but emotional support for Nani, showcasing the importance of a community in overcoming hardships—broadening the definition of family.

Will fans of the original appreciate the changes? While some may not agree with the alterations, the new film explores relevant themes that resonate with today’s audiences, potentially cultivating a deeper understanding of family dynamics.

Ultimately, whether you’re a longtime fan or new to the story, the live-action Lilo & Stitch provides a contemporary lens through which to view familiar themes. For a deeper dive into these narratives and more content like this, explore Moyens I/O.