In the epic showdown of Superman vs. Man of Steel, we witness a clash of titans that surpasses anything seen since the 1983 film Superman III. Fast forward to 2025, and the stakes are higher than ever, as James Gunn’s latest film has overtaken the records set by Zack Snyder’s 2013 Man of Steel. As of July 30, Gunn’s Superman has raked in nearly $297 million at the domestic box office, surpassing Snyder’s film, which stood at around $291 million. This positions Gunn’s film as the highest-grossing domestic Superman movie to date.
However, this victory comes with notable caveats. When considering inflation, Man of Steel would be equivalent to about $405 million in today’s dollars, while Richard Donner’s classic 1978 film might reach nearly $620 million. Therefore, while Superman has outperformed its predecessor domestically, it still lags significantly on a global scale, where Man of Steel earned $379 million compared to Gunn’s film’s current international total of $219 million. Gunn has addressed this disparity in recent interviews.
Why do these numbers matter? They resonate deeply in the context of James Gunn and Peter Safran’s revitalized DC Universe, which has chosen to move past Henry Cavill’s Superman portrayal. For many fans, this new direction represents the final chapter of the Snyderverse—an era defined by Zack Snyder’s unique vision from 2013 through 2022, culminating in the release of Zack Snyder’s Justice League. While this transition has been met with mixed reactions, many Snyder supporters briefly held hope that Gunn’s film would not surpass Snyder’s achievements. So far, that hope appears dashed.
Moreover, it’s essential to acknowledge that Man of Steel‘s earnings reflect its entire three-month box office run, while Superman is currently in its third week. There’s ample time for it to amass even higher figures. The battle between these two cinematic interpretations of Superman is far from finished, with Gunn’s film currently holding a strong lead.
Are you feeling torn between these two films? Do you prefer the storytelling of one over the other? Share your thoughts below.
Want more io9 news? Check out when to expect the latest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s next for the DC Universe on film and TV, and everything you need to know about the future of Doctor Who.
What are the main differences between Superman and Man of Steel? The two films differ significantly in tone, storytelling, and character development, reflecting the distinct visions of their directors. Gunn aims for a more light-hearted and engaging take, while Snyder’s version is darker and more dramatic.
Is there a chance for Henry Cavill to return as Superman? Given the current direction of the DC Universe under Gunn and Safran, Cavill’s return seems unlikely, as the focus is shifting towards a new narrative that lays the groundwork for future characters.
How is box office performance measured against inflation? Box office performance adjusted for inflation provides a more accurate context for how films compare over time, taking into account the changes in ticket prices and consumer spending.
What could this new direction mean for future DC films? With Gunn at the helm, fans can expect a fresh approach to storytelling, focusing on character development and interconnected narratives that could revitalize the DC brand.
If you enjoyed this discussion on superhero cinema and want to dive deeper into the entertainment universe, check out more articles at Moyens I/O.