Krampus is making a return in the 2025 edition of Phasmophobia’s festive Winter’s Jest event, bringing along a brand new twist with the Naughty-or-Nice List. If you thought you could predict what he wanted this time around, think again! This fresh feature wasn’t part of last year’s event and can be quite a puzzle to solve. But don’t worry, I’m here to guide you through how to tackle the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia.
How to Help with the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia
To chip away at the Naughty-or-Nice List task during Winter’s Jest, you’re going to need to find, collect, and return all items mentioned on the brown sack located on each event map. Think of yourself as Krampus’s little helper gathering rewards for him. Completing this task is your ticket to racking up some serious event points!
Where to Find the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia
The Naughty-or-Nice List is easy to spot. Look for it attached to a brown sack near the front door of all the active event maps for the day. Keep in mind that this list is unique for each map, switching things up for every contract!
How to Find Items for Krampus’ Naughty-or-Nice List Sack in Phasmophobia
To hunt down the items for Krampus’s Naughty-or-Nice List, you’ll want to explore the event maps. Each day features four locations decked out for the Winter’s Jest celebration. You’ll find small gifts tucked away on tables, floors, and various surfaces. Grab these goodies and return them to the sack to complete your objective and score those event points.
What Items Do You Put in the Winter’s Jest Sack in Phasmophobia?
The treasures you’re after include small gifts scattered throughout the active Winter’s Jest maps. Each contract will list specific items you need to drop into the sack. The items will be marked next to their names on the list, and as you toss them in, they will be checked off so you know where you stand.
All Naughty-or-Nice List Items in Phasmophobia
There are 12 festive items you might need to track down around the Winter’s Jest maps. You won’t always have to find all of them, just the ones indicated on your specific contract list. You’ll see little drawings next to each item name to help you identify them, but matching these images to the actual items could prove tricky.
| Item | Image | List | Where to Find |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coal |  |
Naughty | Near fireplaces, on tables, on the ground, and on other surfaces |
| Gingerbread Cookie |  |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Mini Christmas Trees |  |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Holiday Star |  |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Bear |  |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Trash |  |
Naughty | On the ground, close to trash cans, in sinks |
| Elf doll |  |
Nice | On tables, sinks, toilets, and other surfaces |
| Sticks |  |
Naughty | On the ground, on tables, and on other surfaces |
| Candy Cane |  |
Nice | On tables and other surfaces |
| Nutcracker |  |
Nice | On boxes, tables, beds, sinks, and other surfaces |
| Reindeer |  |
Nice | On tables, boxes, windowsills, and other surfaces |
| Snowman |  |
Nice | On tables, beds, boxes, and other surfaces |
General tips: If you’re looking for gingerbread cookies or candy canes, head straight to kitchens or dining tables. Coal? Check by the fireplace. And as for trash? Well, don’t stray too far from the bins!
What Happens When You Complete the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia?
After you’ve dutifully placed all the needed items in the Naughty-or-Nice List sack, you’ll see a red box pop out nearby. Go ahead and interact with this box to claim your prize. My first box contained a snowball gun! Others might open with snacks or even collectibles from past Winter’s Jest events. We’re still discovering what goodies lie inside, so check back for updates!
Be careful, though! Tossing in an incorrect item will result in the sack filling up with coal. Yes, you’ll still receive a red box, but it’ll be filled with coal instead of a charming prize. If this happens, you’ll have to wait for your next contract to try again.
And remember, if you want to rack up even more event points, don’t forget to find and open all of Krampus’s jack-in-the-boxes as you explore.
How do you spot the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia?
The Naughty-or-Nice List is attached to a brown sack right near the front door of all active event maps.
What items do I need for the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia?
You’ll need to collect small gifts that will be listed next to the Naughty-or-Nice List on the sack. Specific items will vary from map to map.
Can I fail the Naughty-or-Nice List task in Phasmophobia?
Yes, if you place any item not listed on the sack, it will fill up with coal, and you won’t be able to add more items until your next contract.
What rewards can I get from the Naughty-or-Nice List in Phasmophobia?
Completing the Naughty-or-Nice List will reward you with special prizes, like winter-themed items and collectibles.
Are there other ways to earn event points in Phasmophobia?
Yes! Another way to score points is by finding and opening Krampus’s jack-in-the-boxes, which can yield even more surprises!
So, are you ready to help Krampus fill that sack? Dive right in, and let me know what treasures you find below!