Superman’s cinematic journey has been anything but ordinary. From the enduring hope embodied by Christopher Reeve to the contentious intensity of Henry Cavill, and now James Gunn’s anticipated take in Superman (2025), each era has redefined the meaning of the Man of Steel. While some films soared with innovative vision, others faltered and became lessons in storytelling missteps. Yet, through it all, Superman has remained a reflection of our shared hope. Here, we rank every major Superman movie from worst to best, considering not just box office figures but their lasting impact on fans and culture.
Note:
This ranking is subjective, based on the popularity of the films and my personal preferences.
10. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987)
It’s tough to say, but The Quest for Peace stands as the low point in Superman’s film legacy. The ambitious theme of Superman advocating for nuclear disarmament could have resonated deeply, yet budget cuts from Cannon Films left the movie looking unfinished. With recycled flying sequences and an unconvincing villain named Nuclear Man, even Christopher Reeve’s dedicated performance couldn’t save it. Many fans opt to skip this installment during rewatch marathons.
9. Superman III (1983)
Superman III, after the success of its predecessor, illustrated how drastically a franchise could wane. Leaning heavily on slapstick comedy, the film prioritized Richard Pryor’s humorous subplot over Superman’s narrative. Although there are some standout moments, the overall tone felt misaligned with fans’ expectations for a grand Superman story. Today, it’s revisited more for curiosity than admiration, leading to its low rank on this list.
8. Justice League (2017)
This is the Superman film that many fans wish they could overlook. Rushed reshoots and a sudden change in directors resulted in a film that felt disjointed and lifeless. The infamous CGI-erased mustache overshadowed most of what the film offered. Although it had a few enjoyable moments, the 2017 Justice League is often seen as a lesson in mishandling beloved characters.
7. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)
Batman v Superman divided audiences sharply. For some, it was the long-awaited duel between two iconic characters, while others found it bogged down by a grim narrative. The infamous “Martha” moment became a popular meme, yet Henry Cavill’s portrayal connected with those who appreciated Snyder’s ambition to present these heroes as modern myths. While the film is not without merits, its flaws are glaringly evident.
6. Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)
The release of Zack Snyder’s Justice League marked a significant moment in fan activism, demonstrating the power of audience voices. Though clocking in at four hours, this version provided Superman with the depth he deserved. Fans revered Cavill’s portrayal in the iconic black suit, leading to a mixed but ultimately positive reception. While the film remains uneven, it represents a crucial moment in the legacy of Superman.
5. Man of Steel (2013)
Man of Steel served as a reboot filled with its own controversies. Zack Snyder depicted Superman in a darker and more destructive light than anticipated. While the climactic battles left some uncomfortable, Cavill’s portrayal made the character relatable to a new generation. By emphasizing Superman as an outsider, it struck a chord with certain audiences, helping it find its place within the pantheon of Superman films.
4. Superman Returns (2006)
Released amid a hunger for action-packed superhero narratives, Superman Returns initially felt subdued. Nevertheless, over time, its quiet charm and Brandon Routh’s Reeve-esque performance have gained appreciation. While it may not feature the nonstop action many craved, its emotional resonance has turned it into a heartfelt homage, fostering a different kind of legacy for the franchise.
3. Superman II (1980 / The Donner Cut)
Superman II introduced General Zod, one of the most iconic villains in comic book history. The film expertly blended drama, action, and complex character struggles, making it memorable. The later-released Donner Cut added further layers to this beloved sequel, showcasing how superhero narratives can be both thrilling and emotionally impactful.
2. Superman (1978)
Superman (1978) was a game-changer for the superhero genre, bringing a sincere performance from Christopher Reeve that redefined what a hero could be. Its innovative special effects and unforgettable score created a sense of wonder that still resonates. This film didn’t merely define Superman; it set a precedent for superhero storytelling, carving a place in cinematic history.
1. Superman (2025)
And here we are at Superman (2025). Directed by James Gunn, this isn’t merely another reboot; it stands out for getting it right. Critics hail it as heartfelt, hopeful, and modern without losing that quintessential Superman optimism. Remarkably, it has united both critics and fans, signaling it might be the Superman film audiences have been waiting for. This film doesn’t just claim the top spot; it sets a new standard for this beloved character’s cinematic future.
As you contemplate these rankings, I’m sure some of you might have differing opinions. What’s your favorite Superman movie? Share your thoughts in the comments below. For more intriguing insights and discussions, continue exploring related content at Moyens I/O.